
Russian Physicist Proposes a New Explanation for the Origins of Multicellular Life.
How did individual cells learn to cooperate and form complex organisms billions of years ago?
Alexei Melkikh, a professor at Ural Federal University, argues that random mutations and natural selection alone are insufficient to explain this transition. In a paper published in the scientific journal BioSystems, he proposes a concept of law-governed symbiosis, suggesting that the development of living systems may follow deeper underlying principles. Other studies, however, indicate that evolution can produce complex multicellular structures by building on mechanisms that already existed in single-celled ancestors.
From a Single Cell to a Complex Organism
The emergence of multicellular organisms was one of the most consequential developments in the history of life on Earth.
For billions of years, living organisms existed predominantly as individual cells. Then, in different evolutionary lineages, cells began forming groups capable of functioning as integrated systems.
Over time, this process gave rise to animals, plants, fungi, and other multicellular forms of life.
But how exactly did the transition occur?
At first glance, the problem seems relatively straightforward: several cells come together, begin interacting, and gradually acquire specialized functions.
In reality, however, even a relatively simple multicellular organism is an extraordinarily complex system in which a vast number of processes must be coordinated.
Cells must remain connected, exchange substances and signals, regulate their division, recognize neighboring cells, and respond to environmental changes.
In more complex organisms, they also develop specialized functions. Some provide movement, others obtain nutrients, while still others perform protective or reproductive roles.
This problem has attracted the attention of Alexei Melkikh, a professor in the Department of Physics at Ural Federal University in Russia.
In his paper, Deceptive Simplicity and Law-Governed Symbiosis: A Critical Mini-Review of the Mechanisms Underlying the Emergence of Multicellular Organisms, published on October 6, 2026, in BioSystems, Melkikh examines the origins of multicellularity from the perspectives of systems theory and control theory.
His central argument is that the complexity of coordinated cellular activity is difficult to explain through the gradual accumulation of random changes.
Why Random Mutations May Not Be Enough
Modern evolutionary theory identifies hereditary variation, natural selection, genetic drift, and other processes as mechanisms through which living organisms change over time.
Mutations generate new genetic variants, while natural selection favors the spread of variants that provide an advantage under particular environmental conditions.
Melkikh questions whether these mechanisms are sufficient to explain the emergence of complex, coordinated biological systems.
In his view, the formation of multicellular organisms requires more than the appearance of individual beneficial mutations. It demands the coordinated development of numerous interdependent mechanisms.
Cells, for example, must distinguish components belonging to their own organism from foreign material, communicate through signaling molecules, and perform specific functions within a larger system.
Melkikh compares the challenge to building a computer network.
Simply connecting several computers with cables is not enough to create a functioning internet. The devices must exchange information according to established protocols and coordinate their activities.
Similarly, he argues, cells cannot become an integrated organism without specialized control mechanisms.
To illustrate the complexity of evolutionary search, the researcher considers marine sponges, among the earliest lineages of multicellular animals.
He compares the approximate number of sponges that may have existed over hundreds of millions of years with the enormous number of theoretically possible genome configurations.
Even assuming a very high estimate of the total number of organisms that have ever lived, that figure remains vastly smaller than the number of potential genetic combinations.
From such calculations, Melkikh concludes that the origins of multicellularity cannot be explained by a random search through all possible genetic configurations.
His paper also draws on concepts from computational complexity theory, treating the emergence of coordinated cellular systems as a problem involving an extraordinarily large number of possible operations.
The Concept of Law-Governed Symbiosis
As an alternative to explanations centered on random mutations and natural selection, Melkikh proposes a concept he calls law-governed symbiosis.
Under this hypothesis, the association of individual cells is viewed as a process governed by internal principles that determine how biological structures are formed.
The researcher suggests that control mechanisms may exist that guide the development of complex living systems and coordinate the behavior of their components.
More broadly, he portrays evolution as a directed process in which randomness plays a secondary role.
Melkikh associates the possible origins of these mechanisms with fundamental physical laws. In particular, he raises the possibility that hidden parameters in quantum-mechanical descriptions could influence biological pattern formation.
This is the most ambitious — and also the most controversial — aspect of his proposal.
The suggestion that deeper physical laws might influence biological organization does not, by itself, provide experimental evidence that evolution follows a predetermined program.
The published paper primarily presents theoretical arguments and a review of existing research rather than experimental confirmation of the proposed mechanism.
What Modern Evolutionary Biology Tells Us
The questions raised by Melkikh concern some of the most challenging problems in modern biology.
However, the conclusion that conventional evolutionary mechanisms cannot account for the emergence of multicellularity is not generally accepted.
Indeed, research in recent years has demonstrated that the transition to multicellular organization can occur through several different pathways.
On October 7, 2026, just one day after Melkikh’s paper appeared, Nature published an extensive review by an international research team led by G. Ozan Bozdag and William Ratcliff.
The authors examined current evidence concerning the origins of multicellularity and concluded that some evolutionary challenges that appear almost insurmountable may be overcome through the use of cellular mechanisms that already exist.
One of the review’s central conclusions is that complex properties do not necessarily have to emerge simultaneously.
New functions can gradually evolve from structures that originally served entirely different purposes.
For example, molecules involved in interactions between single-celled organisms and their environments may later have been recruited for communication between cells within a multicellular organism.
This process is known as exaptation: the evolutionary adoption of an existing biological feature for a new function.
The gradual modification of preexisting mechanisms means that evolution need not be understood as a random search among every possible configuration of a fully formed complex organism. Instead, it can proceed through a sequence of intermediate transformations.
When Cells Come Together
In February 2026, Nature published a study of Choanoeca flexa, a species of choanoflagellate belonging to a group of close single-celled relatives of animals.
Researchers found that this organism can form multicellular structures in several different ways.
In some cases, daughter cells remain connected after division. In others, previously independent cells come together. A combination of these mechanisms is also possible.
Moreover, transitions between unicellular and multicellular states are associated with changes in environmental conditions, including fluctuations in water salinity.
The discovery demonstrated that the formation of cellular groups can be considerably more flexible than previously thought.
Another study, published in Nature in June 2026, demonstrated that Ministeria vibrans, a single-celled relative of animals, can form stable cellular aggregates.
These associations involve mechanisms of cellular interaction and regulation related to those that later became essential components of multicellular animal organization.
Such findings suggest that some of the molecular tools required for multicellularity had already evolved in single-celled ancestors.
Evolution Can Be Observed in the Laboratory
Additional evidence comes from experiments involving artificial selection in microorganisms.
In 2023, researchers reported in Nature the results of a long-term experiment involving so-called snowflake yeast — forms of ordinary yeast whose daughter cells remain attached after division.
In the laboratory, scientists systematically selected larger cellular clusters.
After 600 rounds of selection, one experimental lineage had evolved macroscopic multicellular structures approximately 20,000 times larger than the original clusters.
The structures had also developed substantially greater mechanical strength.
Of course, these yeast clusters did not evolve into animals with complex organs and tissues.
Nevertheless, the experiment demonstrated that selection can gradually alter the properties of multicellular structures, including their size and strength.
It provides an important example of how complex collective characteristics can emerge without requiring the simultaneous creation of a complete system of cellular coordination.
Chance and Natural Laws Are Not Mutually Exclusive
In evaluating Melkikh’s hypothesis, it is particularly important to distinguish between two concepts: the randomness of genetic changes and the randomness of evolution as a whole.
Modern biology does not describe evolution as an exclusively chaotic process.
Mutations may arise independently of an organism’s needs, but natural selection is not a random search through possible variants.
Instead, it systematically changes the frequencies of hereditary traits according to their effects on survival and reproduction.
Furthermore, different regions of the genome have different mutation probabilities, while biological and physical constraints influence which changes can arise and become established.
Consequently, portraying evolution as a choice between complete randomness and strict natural laws does not accurately reflect current scientific understanding.
The existence of underlying regularities does not necessarily imply that the development of life follows a predetermined program.
There is another difficulty with arguments based on the enormous number of possible genetic combinations.
Evolution does not require organisms to explore every conceivable genome in sequence.
New organisms arise from earlier forms, inherit biological mechanisms that already function, and change incrementally. The vast number of theoretically possible genetic combinations therefore does not demonstrate that a particular evolutionary transition is impossible.
The relevant question is whether accessible sequences of changes exist that can produce new functions, and how natural selection can act on intermediate stages.
These are precisely the questions that researchers are investigating experimentally.
One of the Great Mysteries in the History of Life
Alexei Melkikh’s concept draws attention to a fundamental problem: how did individual cells become components of a single, coordinated biological system?
But the existence of this problem does not mean that modern evolutionary theory has been shown to be inadequate.
The hypothesis of law-governed symbiosis has yet to receive the experimental support required for it to become an established alternative explanation for the origins of multicellular organisms.
At the same time, new research demonstrates that evolutionary mechanisms can generate forms of cellular cooperation that once seemed extraordinarily difficult to produce.
A fuller understanding of how multicellular life originated will likely require the integration of evolutionary biology, genetics, biophysics, and the study of complex systems.
This is where Melkikh’s approach may prove valuable: as an attempt to formulate questions about coordination and control in biological systems at a more general theoretical level.
Ultimately, however, the answers will depend not on the persuasiveness of mathematical analogies or the apparent magnitude of biological complexity, but on experimental evidence.
For the central mystery is not simply how several cells managed to join together.
It is how those cells gradually became an organism capable of living, developing, and reproducing as a single, integrated whole.





